BOURBON — It’s official: town water in Bourbon will no longer contain added fluoride. Town council members unanimously voted to omit added fluoride during their regularly scheduled meeting Tuesday.
“I see no reason to continue with it,” said council president Les McFarland.
McFarland added that he had conducted research online about the pros and cons of including fluoride in public water supplies. He also took into consideration a letter he received from Indiana Water Fluoridation Program manager James Powers, detailing the benefits of adding fluoride.
Bourbon resident Jonah Best commented, expressing concern that some children in the Triton school system do not get enough fluoride from other sources outside of public water.
“Are (students) really getting what they need, with economy like it is at times in this area?” asked Best. “I would just like the council to consider if this is something you want to do.”
Water/wastewater department head Mike Shoda replied with his belief that children do not drink much water anyway and instead consume other beverages such as juice, soft drinks, and sports drinks.
Shoda also said that the issue was first addressed in last month’s meeting because he was told by the town’s water inspector that adding fluoride was not required by law. He also mentioned that homes with a reverse osmosis unit do not have fluoridated water anyway because the process takes the fluoride out.
During the vote, council member P.J. Hanley commented, “We can always put (the fluoride) back in.”
In other business:
• Bourbon Public Library director Heather Barron visited the council to seek support for the library’s annual summer reading program. Council members agreed to donate $250 to the program.
• Police chief Bill Martin sought the council’s approval to hire Marshall County deputy Travis O’Neal to work in his department part-time.
Martin commented that one of his officers is “not really working out” and that Officer McIntyre’s recent health issues have left the department shorthanded. The council approved Martin’s request.
• The town is seeking a new member for the plan commission following the passing of Democrat member Herb Baker. McFarland advised that interested individuals should submit a letter of interest and a resume to the clerk’s office.
“Whoever replaces (Baker) will have some big shoes to fill,” said McFarland. “We want to thank his family for their support behind the scenes as well.”
Council member Larry Wattenbarger also commented, saying, “I am very much appreciative of (Baker’s) service to the community and what it meant. You won’t find anyone more loyal.”
Comments
Fluoridation Ineffective & Harmful, studies show
March 20, 2012 by Anonymous, 1 year 9 weeks ago
Comment: 13966
Fluoridation Opposition is Scientific, Respectable & Growing
More than 4,038 professionals (including 331 dentists and 518 MD’s) urge that fluoridation be stopped citing scientific evidence that ingesting fluoride is ineffective at reducing tooth decay and has serious health risks. See statement: http://www.fluoridealert.org/professionals-statement.aspx
The CDC reports that 60% of US adolescents are afflicted with dental fluorosis - white spotted, yellow, brown and/or pitted teeth from ingesting too much fluoride. Yet, tooth decay crises are occurring in all fluoridated cities, states and countries. See: http://www.FluorideNews.blogspot.com . This after 67 years of water fluoridation, 57 years of fluoridated toothpaste, a glut of fluoridated dental products and pharmaceuticals.
-- All baby foods contain fluoride, according to research presented at the 2012 annual meeting of the International Association of Dental Research
-- Commonly-consumed infant fruit juices contain fluoride, some at levels higher than recommended for pubic water supplies, according to research was presented 3/17/2011 at the International Association for Dental Research annual meeting in San Diego
-- All infant formula, whether concentrated or not, contain fluoride at levels that can discolor teeth - even organic, according to research published in the October 2009 Journal of the American Dental Association.
-- HHS Assistant Secretary for Health, Dr. Howard Koh, says all infant formulas, either concentrated or ready-to-feed, already contain some fluoride and, when routinely mixed with fluoridated water, increase the risk of dental fluorosis (discolored teeth), in a video commentary published on Medscape.com, March 8, 2011 References http://www.FormulaFluoride.Webs.com
Adverse health effects of fluoride http://www.FluorideAction.Net/health
Which studies? Do share.
March 25, 2012 by Anonymous, 1 year 8 weeks ago
Comment: 13971
What a curious collection of nonsense the previous post contains.
These 331 dentists constitute approximately 0.22% of U.S. dentists, provided they all live in the States, while almost all of the rest are members of a fluoride advocacy organization called the American Dental Association.
High levels of fluoride in water cause fluorosis, which is almost always cosmetic and overwhelmingly mild. Meanwhile, low levels of fluoride bring increased cavities, which most of us eventually have to deal with and which is greatly reduced by water fluoridation. There's not even a hint of comparison here.
All the fearmongering over the fluoride content of food is premised on the idea that fluoride is bad for you in any dose — even though the National Research Council includes fluoride (the main ion of fluorine) among "the mineral elements currently considered essential for human health and metabolism".
(By the way, here's that October 2009 article from the ADA. From the abstract (emphasis mine): "When powdered or liquid concentrate infant formulas are the primary source of nutrition, some infants are likely to exceed the recommended fluoride upper limit if the formula is reconstituted with water containing 1.0 ppm fluoride. On the other hand, when the fluoride concentration in water used to reconstitute infant formulas is below 0.4 ppm, it is likely that infants between 6 and 12 months of age will be exposed to fluoride at levels below IOM’s recommended adequate intake level." The claim that "[a]ll infant formula, whether concentrated or not, contain fluoride at levels that can discolor teeth" is fabricated.)
In addition to endorsing water fluoridation, the CDC presents statistics (made into a graph for easy viewing) showing that an increasing percentage of U.S. citizens receive fluoridated, rather than fluoride-free, water.
It is interesting to ponder the extent of the conspiracy in which the CDC, the ADA, and hundreds of other organizations must be complicit in order to perpetuate this supposedly dangerous, unproven practice. (Meanwhile, see if you can find anyone terrified of fluoride who doesn't get their information from the Fluoride Action Network.) Sorry, but fluoridation opposition is anti-scientific, harmful, and thankfully shrinking.
Effects of Fluoride
March 25, 2012 by Anonymous, 1 year 8 weeks ago
Comment: 13970
According to a retired orthopedic surgeon,* its other effects include these:--
- Relatively slow mental processes.
- Low motility of male gametes, & thus,
- Infertility.
- Fluorosis of bones, which contributes to hip fractures.
There was high Mortality among Senior Citizens whose hips broke.
_________________________
* -- I.e., Stanley Monteith, whose MD degree was conferred by the Univ. of Cal. _ His credentials appear on his website, located @ www.RadioLiberty.com/doc.htm